Discussion about this post

User's avatar
John's avatar

While I agree with some points, one-sided teaching does little but simply add soldiers to the other side. If you want enlightened students, capable of critical thinking, then rather than fear-based teachings like you've stated, I suspect they would be better served understanding the ideals of the various models, first. Then the challenges in bringing those to reality and how things have gone through history and why. How are they constructed, who controls them, what happens if certain groups within them become corrupt?

There are democracies with socialist leanings that are successful. An educated citizenry is critical to a successful democracy. If your measure of success is purely wealth then capitalism should win. However if happiness/contentment are the measure, raw capitalism falls short. There is a balance between wealth and security. Many feel that a society's greatness is measured by how it treats its weakest members.

Discussing all of these aspects gives a student a much stronger ability to spot ideological thinking and the partisan, tribalism that comes with it.

Expand full comment
Viraj Shah's avatar

Capitalism is a "perfect" system assuming you price everything appropriately (e.g., negative externalities like pollution, or the impact of positive externalities like teaching) yet in the real world everyone has different values, order of priorities, and greed so you get fossil fuels which are insanely subsidized, GMO crops which are incentivized, teachers who are paid like crap, and pharma in the US advertising pills as the solution to everything.

Socialism / communism is a "perfect" system assuming everyone outputs a reasonably similar amount of "value" and no one wants more than anyone else yet in the real world, it's the same problems - everyone has different values, order of priorities, greed so you get corrupt despots, supply shortages, and violence.

They're both perfect in their ideals, but imperfect in their realities. It's great to understand *why* the younger generation is fed up with capitalism. Sure, some of it is a lack of historical understanding, but understanding why tells you what's imperfect about the current system and how we can improve. I think these labels should be treated like guide posts. They just describe ends of a spectrum and the reality is that we ought to, yes, consider history but also recognize the ever changing present and future to come up with the best system that works for us now regardless of the label.

I also recommend making your course open and accessible if you're trying to share your message wildly and publicly.

Expand full comment
42 more comments...

No posts